Stakeholders Rejecting the Plan? Codesign vs Consultation

Last Modified: November 22, 2026

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
The difference between codesign and consultation, when each is right, how a codesign workshop runs, who should take part and what you should receive.

Consultation asks people to react to an idea you have already shaped. Codesign brings them in earlier, while the idea is still forming, so they help define the problem as well as the solution. Choose consultation when the options are genuinely limited and you need feedback. Choose codesign when the people affected know something you do not, and when their support will decide whether the change succeeds. This article explains the difference, when to use each, how a codesign workshop runs and what you should come away with.

In short

  • Consultation gathers feedback on a proposal. Codesign creates the proposal together.
  • Codesign suits new services, community projects, internal change and brand work involving staff and customers.
  • Good codesign is structured and inclusive, so quieter voices carry equal weight.
  • Recruitment and synthesis matter as much as the workshop itself.
  • The output should be clear design principles and priorities, not a wall of sticky notes.

Sound familiar?

  • A new strategy, service or space was designed, and staff or customers rejected it.
  • You ran a consultation and the feedback felt like a list of complaints.
  • Stakeholders feel decisions were made before they were asked.
  • Leadership wants buy in but is nervous about losing control of the outcome.
  • You are not sure whether a survey, a focus group or a workshop is the right tool.

Codesign helps when people need to shape the answer, not just react to it.

What is codesign?

Codesign is an approach where the people affected by a product, service or change work alongside your team to shape it. Participants might be customers, staff, community members, partners or a mix. They contribute their experience and ideas from the start, rather than responding to a finished concept.

The approach draws on human centred design: understanding real needs and experiences before deciding on solutions.

Codesign and consultation compared

Consultation Codesign
When people get involved After a proposal exists While the problem and options are being defined
Their role Respond and give feedback Contribute ideas and shape the solution
Typical format Surveys, submissions, information sessions Facilitated workshops, often a series
Best when Options are limited, decisions are largely made The people affected hold knowledge you need
Main benefit Efficient feedback at scale Better solutions and genuine ownership

Neither is better in every situation. Consultation done honestly is valuable. The problem is consultation presented as codesign, where people sense the decision is already made.

When codesign is the right choice

  • New products, services and customer experiences. Customers can describe what frustrates them and what would help in ways internal teams miss.
  • Community consultation and stakeholder engagement. Councils, government agencies and infrastructure projects get better outcomes, and less opposition, when communities shape options.
  • Not for profit programs. Programs designed with the people they serve fit real lives better.
  • Internal change. New ways of working land more easily when the staff affected help design them.
  • Brand and naming projects. Involving staff and customers early builds support for the result. A short codesign workshop with leadership is also a valuable step in brand strategy.

How a codesign workshop runs

Discover

Start with your team: what the project needs to achieve, what is fixed and what is open, and who is affected. Map stakeholders and plan recruitment so the right mix of people attend.

Design the session

Choose activities that suit the group. A codesign session for community members looks very different from one for senior executives. Typical activities include journey mapping, sharing experiences, generating ideas, testing rough concepts and prioritising.

Facilitate

On the day, the facilitator’s job is to make the session safe and productive: explaining the purpose honestly, drawing out quieter voices, managing dominant ones and capturing ideas as they emerge.

Distil

After the session comes synthesis: drawing out themes from what was heard and turning them into clear design principles and priorities. This is where many codesign efforts fall down. Without synthesis, participants’ input never makes it into the work.

Play it back

Where possible, show participants what you heard and what happens next. It builds trust and often improves the result.

Who should take part?

Aim for a mix of people who will use, deliver or be affected by the outcome. Consider:

  • people with different levels of experience and different needs,
  • frontline staff as well as managers,
  • people who are usually underrepresented,
  • a small number of decision makers, participating rather than presiding.

Group size depends on the activity, but smaller groups of eight to fifteen allow everyone to contribute meaningfully. Larger projects often run several sessions.

Common mistakes

  1. Deciding first, then “codesigning”. People notice, and trust suffers.
  2. Inviting the usual voices only. You hear what you already know.
  3. Letting senior people dominate. Participants defer, and the session becomes consultation.
  4. No synthesis. Ideas stay on the wall.
  5. No follow up. Participants never learn what happened to their input.

Why an independent facilitator helps

Codesign depends on participants feeling safe to speak honestly. An independent facilitator has no stake in the outcome, can manage power dynamics fairly and can tell your team things that are hard to hear. Our codesign workshops cover discovery, recruitment planning, facilitation and synthesis.

Codesign often connects to other work. A strategy day may come first to align leadership. A Brand Health Check gathers perceptions through confidential interviews rather than workshops. And when a town hall announces the change that codesign shaped, town hall facilitation helps leaders explain it well.

What a good codesign outcome looks like

A codesign process is working when participants recognise their ideas in the final result, even where not every suggestion was adopted. Signs of a strong outcome include:

  • A clear record of what was heard, and how it shaped the decision.
  • Ideas that leadership would not have reached alone.
  • Participants who can explain the decision to their own colleagues.
  • Fewer objections at launch, because concerns were raised and addressed earlier.
  • A shared language for the problem that continues after the workshop.

It is equally important to be honest about limits. Codesign does not mean every decision is made by vote. Leadership still sets the boundaries, chooses between options and owns the result. Explaining those limits at the start builds trust, because people know exactly how their input will be used. When participants later see their ideas reflected in a new strategy, service or brand, they become its strongest advocates. That is the real return on codesign, and it is why the investment in a well designed session usually pays for itself in smoother implementation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a codesign workshop?

A structured session where the people affected by a product, service or change work alongside your team to shape it.

How many sessions does codesign need?

Some projects need one session; larger ones a short series. The scope depends on the number of stakeholder groups and the complexity of the problem.

Can codesign run online?

Yes. Online sessions in Zoom, Teams and Miro work well, particularly for spread out groups.

Is codesign slower than consultation?

It can take longer upfront, but it often saves time later by reducing opposition, rework and failed rollouts.

What do we receive at the end?

A synthesis of what was heard, clear design principles and priorities, and a findings report your team can build on.

Next steps

If the people affected by your project know something you need to hear, explore codesign workshops or get in touch to plan the right approach.

Soto Group are a full service creative agency delivering impactful brands, websites and marketing strategies.

7 + 4 =