Hired a Marketer and It Did Not Work? How to Get Your First Marketing Hire Right

Last Modified: November 22, 2026

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Why first marketing hires often fail, and how to get yours right: role design, recruitment, onboarding, training and ongoing management.

First marketing hires often struggle for a simple reason: the business hires a junior or mid level coordinator, then expects them to set strategy, produce everything and manage themselves, with nobody experienced to guide them. The hire is rarely the whole problem. Success depends on a clear role, a structured recruitment process, a plan from day one and someone who knows marketing to train and manage them through the first months. This article explains why first hires go wrong, what to get right before you advertise and how to support a new marketer until they can run on their own.

In short

  • The common struggle: a new marketer who is busy but not producing results.
  • Most failures come from unclear roles, no strategy and no experienced manager.
  • Design the role and the plan before you recruit.
  • Test skills during recruitment rather than relying on interviews alone.
  • Structured onboarding and three months of training make the biggest difference.

Sound familiar?

  • You hired a marketer, and six months later nobody is sure what they achieved.
  • The role description asked for strategy, design, social, SEO, ads and events.
  • Nobody in the business knew how to judge their work or set priorities.
  • They spent most of their time on whatever the loudest person asked for.
  • They left, and took everything they knew with them because nothing was documented.

Why first marketing hires go wrong

The role asks for everything

Many position descriptions describe a whole marketing team in one person. A coordinator can be excellent at execution and still not be ready to set strategy. When the role is unrealistic, the hire is set up to disappoint.

There is no plan

Without a strategy, a new marketer fills their days with requests. Activity grows but results do not. Our guide to writing a marketing strategy your team will use explains what that plan should include.

Nobody can manage them

Business owners and operations managers are often asked to supervise marketing without a marketing background. They cannot easily set priorities, review quality or coach. The new hire either flounders or drifts.

Onboarding is an afterthought

A login, a laptop and “have a look around” is not onboarding. New marketers need to understand the brand, the customers, the systems and what success looks like.

Knowledge is not captured

When processes live in one person’s head, every departure resets the clock.

Before you advertise

Step What to decide
Role Execution or strategy? Generalist or specialist? Full time, part time or remote?
Plan What will they work on in the first 90 days, and how will success be measured?
Manager Who will set priorities, review work and coach them?
Pay What the market expects for the skills you need
Tools Which systems they will use: CRM, email platform, website, design tools, scheduling

If nobody inside can lead marketing, decide early whether you will bring in outside support to train and manage the hire. Our comparison of an outsourced marketing department and hiring in house can help with that decision.

Recruiting well

Interviews alone are a poor guide to marketing skill. A stronger process includes:

  • A clear advertisement that describes the real role, not a wish list.
  • Screening for relevant experience and attention to detail.
  • A short, paid or time limited skills test that mirrors real tasks: a social post, an email, a short plan.
  • A shortlist of about three strong candidates for final interviews.
  • Reference checks focused on reliability and initiative.

Remote coordinators and virtual assistants can work well, especially for execution focused roles, provided onboarding and management are strong.

Onboarding and the first 30 days

A good first month includes:

  • Systems setup and access to every tool.
  • A brand and strategy induction, including brand guidelines if you have them.
  • Customer and competitor briefings.
  • A written 30 day plan with clear, achievable tasks.
  • Regular check ins, ideally weekly.

Training through the first three months

The first three months decide whether a hire becomes self sufficient. Weekly one on ones, task planning and quality review build skills quickly. Writing standard operating procedures as you train means knowledge stays in the business, whatever happens later.

Ongoing management

Even capable coordinators benefit from experienced oversight: fortnightly one on ones, monthly performance reviews and a quarterly look at strategy. That oversight can come from inside the business or from an outside marketing lead.

How the marketing team member program works

Our marketing team member program covers each stage:

  • Recruit and onboard: role design, recruitment, a shortlist of three, onboarding and a 30 day plan.
  • Recruit, onboard and train: adds three months of weekly training, quality review and marketing SOPs.
  • Fully managed team member: adds six months of ongoing management and performance reviews.

You employ the team member directly or through their provider. The program pairs well with a marketing strategy, and many clients add graphic design packs so their coordinator has design support. Our article on why marketing looks inconsistent explains why that matters.

For the bigger picture on budgets and priorities, see our guide to marketing a growing business.

What good looks like after six months

By the six month mark, a well supported marketing coordinator should be running the core activity with little day to day direction. Signs of success include:

  • Social media, email and website updates happening on schedule without reminders.
  • Work arriving on brand, accurate and ready for approval with few changes.
  • Monthly reporting that shows what was done, what worked and what is next.
  • Documented procedures for the main recurring tasks.
  • Ideas coming from the coordinator, not just requests flowing to them.
  • A clear relationship with any agencies, designers or suppliers they work with.

If these signs are missing, the cause is usually structural rather than personal: unclear priorities, too many requests from too many people or no regular review. Fixing the structure often turns an average hire into a strong one.

It is also worth planning the next step early. As the coordinator grows, they may take on more strategy, manage suppliers or support a larger team. Regular performance reviews make that growth visible, help you retain good people and ensure the role keeps pace with the business.

Setting clear priorities

New marketers often receive requests from everyone. Agree one person who sets priorities, keep a visible task list and review it weekly. That simple discipline protects time for planned work and stops the loudest request from always winning.

Frequently asked questions

Should our first marketing hire be junior or senior?

It depends on whether you need strategy or execution. A coordinator can succeed if someone experienced sets direction and manages them.

How long does it take to recruit a marketing coordinator?

Typically four to six weeks from brief to start date.

Can a marketing coordinator work remotely?

Yes. Many businesses hire remote coordinators or virtual assistants, with good onboarding and regular check ins.

Who should manage a new marketer if we have no marketing manager?

Either a senior leader with outside coaching support, or an external marketing lead who manages them directly.

What if the hire does not work out?

Documented processes make it easier to recover. A good program includes support to recruit again.

Next steps

If you are ready for your first marketer, set them up to succeed. Explore the marketing team member program or get in touch to talk about the role.

Soto Group are a full service creative agency delivering impactful brands, websites and marketing strategies.

4 + 4 =